The Reading Group 

© Copyright 1999-2005

Pudd'nhead Wilson

Mark Twain (1835-1910)

27th April 2001 at Sam's House

Synopsis

At the beginning of Pudd'nhead Wilson a young slave woman, fearing for her infant's son's life, exchanges her light-skinned child with her master's. From this rather simple premise Mark Twain fashioned one of his most entertaining, funny, yet biting novels. On its surface, Pudd'nhead Wilson possesses all the elements of an engrossing nineteenth-century mystery: reversed identities, a horrible crime, an eccentric detective, a suspenseful courtroom drama, and a surprising, unusual solution. Yet it is not a mystery novel. Seething with the undercurrents of antebellum southern culture, the book is a savage indictment in which the real criminal is society, and racial prejudice and slavery are the crimes.

The flashes of farce and general comic exuberance which enlivened Huckleberry Finn are sustained in this later work; but the mood is altogether more restless and critical. Twain uses certain stock characters and devices, such as the sardonic cracker-barrel philosopher, the scoundrel unmasked, and the substitution of babies, to build up a complex ironical and morally disturbing account of human nature under slavery. Some of the peculiar circumstances in which it was written originally a slight comedy of identity based on Siamese twins, it developed into something much more ambitious, and finally Twain discarded most of the original plot: "I pulled one of the stories out by the roots - a kind of literary Caesarean operation."

First lines

The scene of this chronicle is the town of Dawson's Landing, on the Missouri side of the Mississippi, half a day's journey, per steamboat, below St Louis.

Our comments

Once more we ended up choosing a lesser known Twain as most of us had already read Huckleberry Finn and Tom Sawyer. For those of us that had, this was a slightly disappointing read, lacking the all out quality of those books. But there is a lot to like in this ironic if not cynical look at slavery and the perverse results from such a system.

Your comments

Related resources

Biography on Pegasos site

Pudd'nhead Wilson